A quiet curving residential road beside native desert landscaping and a low estate wall in warm Paradise Valley afternoon light.

Paradise Valley Already Had the Money. This Month's Vote Was About Whether It Could Spend It.

In the fiscal year that ended June 30, 2025, Paradise Valley took in about $58 million and spent about $36 million. The Town added the $22 million difference to its general fund strategic reserves, according to Councilmember Anna Thomasson's year-end report in the Paradise Valley Independent. Even with that surplus, the Town went to voters on November 3 and asked permission to spend more.

Arizona caps how much each city and town can spend in a year using a formula tied to what it spent in fiscal 1979–80. The cap applies even when the Town has more money available. So the pace of drainage, street, sewer and public safety work in Paradise Valley depends on a voter-approved spending limit more than on tax collections. Propositions 426 and 427 were the latest change to that limit.

A Property Tax Line That Reads Zero

Paradise Valley has no municipal property tax for homeowners to pay. Maricopa County's 2025 tax rate table lists the Town's municipal primary and secondary rates as 0.0000. The same table lists other taxing jurisdictions.

Most of the Town's money comes from businesses and visitors. Thomasson's breakdown for the year ending June 30, 2025:

  • Taxes from the Town's resorts: about 35% of revenue
  • Construction sales tax: about 15%
  • Investment income from strategic reserves: just over 10%
  • State-shared revenue: just under 10%
  • Permits, licensing fees, fines, forfeitures and other sources: the balance

Lodging carries a higher local tax rate than retail, which explains how the resorts generate such a large share. The Arizona Department of Revenue's rate table effective January 1, 2026 lists Paradise Valley's retail rate at 2.50%. Hotels pay that same 2.50% plus a 3.40% Hotel/Motel Additional Tax, for 5.90% at the municipal level. Each renovated villa or new room block along the resort corridor, including the work behind the Ritz-Carlton Paradise Valley villas, brings in revenue twice. Construction sales tax comes first, then lodging tax once guests arrive.

The 1980 Formula Tracks People, and Paradise Valley Barely Adds Any

Each year the State Economic Estimates Commission takes the Town's 1979–80 base and adjusts it for population and inflation. Revenue follows resort activity and building permits. The spending limit follows Census counts. In a built-out town with large lots, those two numbers move at very different speeds.

The Town's publicity pamphlet for the election names five things the formula misses:

  1. Construction and reconstruction, both residential and at resorts that have added rooms, renovated or opened.
  2. Visitors and pass-through traffic from surrounding Valley cities, which add wear to roads, sewer and stormwater systems and add demand on public safety.
  3. Owners who do not consider Paradise Valley their primary residence and are not counted in the Census, yet still use Town services.
  4. Pension inflation, one of the Town's largest costs, which rises faster than the general inflation rate in the formula.
  5. Construction inflation, another large cost, which the formula also understates.

The Town has also taken on services it did not provide in 1980. The pamphlet lists sewer infrastructure, fire services, alarm monitoring, visitor promotion, rights-of-way landscaping, stormwater facilities, utility line undergrounding, added police personnel, code enforcement and hillside development services. Several of these affect real estate transactions directly. Sewer coverage determines how a Paradise Valley closing handles septic, and hillside review determines what a sloped lot can hold. All of these services count against a limit set before they existed.

The constitutional provision restricts only what the Town spends. It places no limit on what the Town collects. The Town has raised its base limit with voter approval three times before, in 2000, 2006 and 2016. It is far from alone: 84 of Arizona's 92 municipalities have done the same at least once.

Two Questions on the Ballot, With Different Margins

The two measures address the limit in different ways. Proposition 426 permanently raises the base by $3,940,190 in 1979–80 dollars. State law requires the ballot to state the amount in those dollars, and the Town says it equals $20 million in current dollars. According to the Town's analysis, approval would lift the FY2027–28 spending limit from $51,702,050 to $71,702,050. Proposition 427 creates a Capital Projects Accumulation Fund. Spending from that fund on land, buildings and public infrastructure would not count toward the limit.

The latest count comes from Maricopa County's unofficial results, last updated November 6 at 8:58 p.m.:

Measure

What it does

Yes

No

Yes share

Proposition 426

Raises the base limit by $20 million in current dollars, permanently, for any budget purpose

4,156

2,867

59.18%

Proposition 427

Lets future surpluses fund capital projects outside the limit

4,427

2,557

63.39%

The county reported 7,862 ballots cast and 75.18% turnout. Results stay unofficial until the canvass. In its weekly update for the week ending November 6, the Town described both measures as likely to pass. The capital-only fund drew about 270 more yes votes and about 310 fewer no votes than the general increase.

What the Larger Limit Allows

A higher limit gives the Town permission to spend more. It does not require any spending. Council must still adopt a balanced budget each year, and the Town says neither measure creates a new or higher tax. No formal arguments against either proposition were filed for the pamphlet. Mayor Mark Stanton wrote the arguments in favor, and Thomasson added a second argument for 427. In her campaign argument, which the pamphlet reprints as submitted, Thomasson says hospitality revenue produced $88 million in surplus over five years and that the current budget puts $17 million toward capital improvements.

Charlene Bisson argued for a no vote on 426 in an opinion piece for the Paradise Valley Independent. She described the measure as more than a 40% increase over the current budget in spending capacity and responded to the no-new-taxes point this way:

"True, because we don't have local taxes to raise. But it misleads the voter and misses the point completely. A spending limit exists for a reason: to impose fiscal discipline and force elected officials to establish priorities."

Her point and the Town's point both rest on the zero property tax rate. Because residents pay no Town levy, the spending limit is the only local check on how much revenue becomes services.

The pamphlet also lays out what the Town would face without more room. Spending above the limit without voter approval would cost the Town its state-shared revenue, which was $5,267,070, or 7.6% of the revenue used for operations and infrastructure, in fiscal 2025. The Town's other options would be to delay infrastructure or issue bonds. Bond proceeds do not count against the limit, but they carry interest and repayment costs.

The Capital Fund Starts Empty

The Capital Projects Accumulation Fund begins at zero. Money already in the General Fund balance cannot be moved into it. Only surpluses generated after the fund is set up qualify. Eligible work is defined through the Town's five-year Capital Improvement Program, which covers projects over $100,000 with a useful life of at least three years. The pamphlet's examples are sewer repairs, drainage improvements, power line undergrounding, street and intersection improvements, and police and fire buildings and equipment.

Recent weeks show what that kind of work looks like. The October 30 to November 1 storms dropped between 2.44 and 4.72 inches of rain on Paradise Valley. The Town's crews removed more than 100 tons of material from streets each day and identified nearly 150 locations that needed debris clearing, according to the Town Manager's weekly update. The Invergordon Road and Mockingbird Lane intersection has been fully closed for storm-drain work since October 26. The October 23 update lists Monday, November 23 as the scheduled end, with detours in place and dates subject to change. Signal work is also scheduled on two Thursday nights. The light at Palo Cristi Road and Lincoln Drive will be out from 7 p.m. on Thursday, November 12, until 5 a.m. on Friday, November 13. The light at Tatum Boulevard and Caida Del Sol Drive will be out from 7 p.m. on November 19 until 5 a.m. on November 20.

The ballot measures did not assign any of these projects to the new fund or to the larger limit. They set how much of the Town's resort and construction revenue can be spent on this kind of work each year.

This post is general information about how the Town's finances work. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm how property taxes apply to a specific parcel with a qualified tax professional.

Buyers comparing Paradise Valley with neighboring cities can ask The Jakobov Group to go through a specific property's tax bill line by line, along with the sewer, drainage and hillside details that come up during a Paradise Valley purchase. Schedule a Consultation.

Let's Get Started

Connect with The Jakobov Group for an elite real estate experience. Our expert team provides personalized service, market insights, and unmatched negotiation skills. Let’s achieve your real estate goals. Reach out today!

Follow Us on Instagram